Cover of Sense and Sensibility

Sense and Sensibility Study Guide

A-level set textOCR A-level

Notes cover the whole book.

Characters

Themes

  • Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingChapters 1, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 35, 37, 38, 39, 40, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49 and 50 · 77 key quotes
  • Money, inheritance and greedChapters 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 12, 14, 15, 17, 24, 30, 31, 33, 34, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 44, 47, 49 and 50 · 20 key quotes
  • Love and marriageChapters 3, 4, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 18, 19, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49 and 50 · 38 key quotes
  • Family duty and selfishnessChapters 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 12, 15, 16, 17, 19, 21, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49 and 50 · 32 key quotes
  • Women's dependence and securityChapters 1, 2, 4, 5, 8, 13, 15, 22, 24, 29, 31, 33, 37, 41, 44 and 50 · 8 key quotes
  • Manners, society and sincerityChapters 2, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 30, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 46 and 50 · 39 key quotes

Chapter summaries

  1. Chapter 1

    The novel opens with money: the old owner's will ties Norland up for John Dashwood's small son, so Henry Dashwood cannot provide for his second wife and their daughters. When Henry dies a year later, the women are left with ten thousand pounds, while John, already rich, gains the estate. John promises his dying father to help them and plans to give his sisters three thousand pounds, but the narrator calls him rather cold-hearted and rather selfish, and his wife worse. The three sisters are then set out: Elinor, nineteen, has strong feelings but governs them; Marianne is clever and generous but eager in everything; and Margaret, thirteen, has caught Marianne's romance. Marianne and her mother feed their grief, while Elinor, though deeply afflicted, still deals with her brother and sister-in-law and tries to rouse her mother. The contrast between governing feeling and giving way to it is set out from the first chapter.

  2. Chapter 2

    Fanny becomes mistress of Norland, and the Dashwood women stay as visitors while Mrs Dashwood looks for a house nearby. The main scene is a dialogue in which Fanny, pleading the interests of 'poor little Harry', whittles down John's promised gift step by step. Each suggestion is smaller than the last: three thousand pounds, then five hundred pounds apiece, then a hundred a year for their mother, then fifty pounds now and then, and finally only small favours. Fanny dismisses the sisters as only half blood and claims that four women can live very cheaply on five hundred a year. John himself proposes most of the cuts while insisting that he would not wish to do anything mean. Austen lets the couple condemn themselves through their own reasoning, showing how greed can wear the language of prudence and duty.

  3. Chapter 3

    Mrs Dashwood's search for a house is slowed partly by Elinor's prudence, which rejects houses too large for their income. She trusts John's promise and even blames herself for once doubting his generosity, which the reader already knows is misplaced. Edward Ferrars is introduced as quiet, shy and good, a man who wants domestic comfort while his mother and sister want him to make a fine figure in the world. Mrs Dashwood, who says she has 'never yet known what it was to separate esteem and love', decides at once that Elinor and Edward will marry. Marianne's objections to Edward reveal her own ideals: the man she loves must share every taste and read poetry with passion. Her mother reminds her that she is not yet seventeen and has time.

  4. Chapter 4

    The sisters' talk about Edward sets their two ways of speaking side by side. Elinor uses measured words, 'esteem' and 'like', and Marianne bursts out at them as cold-hearted. Elinor tells Marianne she has scarcely any doubt of his preference, but he depends on a mother who may expect him to marry a woman of great fortune or high rank. Privately, his low spirits sometimes make her fear he feels only friendship. The narrator observes that for Marianne and her mother 'to wish was to hope, and to hope was to expect'. Fanny's pointed talk about young women who try to draw Edward in drives Mrs Dashwood to accept Sir John Middleton's offer at once, without inquiry. Elinor, who had thought it wiser to live at a distance from Norland, does not object.

  5. Chapter 5

    Mrs Dashwood enjoys announcing that she is going to a cottage within four miles north of Exeter, and Edward's surprised 'Devonshire!' shows his concern at their departure. She invites him warmly to show Fanny that she has no wish to part him from Elinor. John is sorry that the distance stops him helping to move the furniture, the very service to which he had shrunk his promise, and Fanny resents Mrs Dashwood keeping any handsome furniture. Elinor's sense keeps the new household small: the carriage is sold and only three servants go with them. Marianne's farewell to the trees of Norland, full of exclamations, shows her habit of dramatising feeling, and also her sense that nature does not share human grief.

  6. Chapter 6

    The family's spirits lift at the sight of Barton Valley, and each resolves to seem happy for the others' sake. The narrator teases the house for not being a proper cottage, with no green shutters and no honeysuckle on the walls. Mrs Dashwood plans extensions to be paid for from savings, though she is 'a woman who never saved in her life'. Sir John is generous and friendly to the point of over-pressing them, sending garden produce, game and his newspaper. Lady Middleton is handsome and well-bred but cold, and her visit is kept going by Sir John's chatter and by talk about her shy son of about six. The scene shows how empty polite conversation can be.

  7. Chapter 7

    Sir John and Lady Middleton are opposites in manner but alike in having little talent or taste: he lives for hunting and company, she for her children and her elegant table. Mrs Jennings teases the girls about lovers left behind in Sussex, and Marianne's anxious looks at Elinor hurt her sister more than the jokes do. Colonel Brandon is silent and grave and past thirty-five, which makes him an old bachelor in the eyes of Marianne and Margaret. When Marianne sings, Sir John talks through every song and Lady Middleton asks for one Marianne has just finished. Only Brandon listens properly, and Marianne respects him for it while assuming that a man of his age has outlived all strong feeling. The narrator's ironic phrase about the colonel's 'advanced state of life' gently mocks Marianne's youthful judgement.

  8. Chapter 8

    With both her daughters married, Mrs Jennings spends her energy arranging other people's matches, and decides from his attentive listening that Colonel Brandon loves Marianne; it would be an excellent match, she thinks, since he is rich and she is handsome. Marianne finds the idea ridiculous and says thirty-five has nothing to do with matrimony; when Elinor suggests a single woman of twenty-seven, Marianne calls such a marriage only a compact of convenience. Elinor and Mrs Dashwood tease her, pointing out that her mother is forty and that the colonel only complained of a slight rheumatic shoulder on a cold, damp day. Marianne is teased that a fever would interest her far more than flannel waistcoats. Alone with her mother, she fears that Edward is ill because he has not come, and cannot understand Elinor's composure at their parting. The chapter shows Marianne judging others by her own standard of open feeling.

  9. Chapter 9

    The Dashwoods settle happily at Barton, though Mrs Dashwood will only visit families within walking distance. Marianne and Margaret set out on the downs, sure the weather will hold, and are caught in a downpour; Marianne falls and is carried home by a stranger. Willoughby's looks, manners and sudden action match the hero of a favourite story, and Marianne's imagination is busy at once. When she asks Sir John about his talents and genius, Sir John can only praise his shooting, his riding and his pointer, which shows how differently the two judge people. Marianne admires eagerness that 'should know no moderation', and she scolds Sir John for the phrase 'setting one's cap'. The chapter introduces a romantic meeting and also shows Marianne judging a man on very little knowledge.

  10. Chapter 10

    During one visit, Marianne and Willoughby seem to agree about music, dancing and favourite books, and Elinor teases her for using up every subject in one morning. Marianne answers that she has been open and sincere where convention wants her 'reserved, spiritless, dull, and deceitful', but softens at once when her mother takes her side. Elinor finds only one fault in Willoughby: like Marianne, he says what he thinks too freely, judges others too fast and slights the forms of propriety. Mrs Dashwood, who thinks him faultless, already counts him and Edward as future sons-in-law. Elinor now sees that Colonel Brandon loves Marianne, and pities him the more because Willoughby and Marianne make fun of him. She defends him with plain reasons, while their attack rests on wit and imagination, and Willoughby can only joke that he dislikes Brandon for warning of rain and finding fault with his curricle.

  11. Chapter 11

    Marianne thinks that hiding feelings which are not wrong in themselves is a disgraceful surrender to 'commonplace and mistaken notions', and Willoughby agrees. They dance together, talk only to each other and are laughed at without shame, while Mrs Dashwood encourages them. Elinor is less happy: Mrs Jennings talks endlessly and Lady Middleton has nothing to say, so only Colonel Brandon offers real conversation. Brandon asks whether Marianne thinks a second attachment impossible; Elinor replies that her opinions are romantic and that experience of the world will be her greatest advantage. Brandon, more gently, finds 'the prejudices of a young mind' amiable and fears what may replace them, and his broken story of a lady like Marianne suggests a sorrow of his own. Elinor asks no more, while the narrator remarks that Marianne would have invented the whole story at once.

  12. Chapter 12

    Marianne accepts the horse without thinking of the cost of a servant and a stable, and when Elinor questions taking such a gift from a man she has known so briefly, she replies that intimacy depends on 'disposition alone', not time. Elinor knows argument will only harden her, so she wins by appealing to Marianne's love for their mother. Willoughby's low reply, using Marianne's Christian name and speaking of her future home, convinces Elinor of an engagement, and Margaret's story of the lock of hair strengthens her belief. Margaret then embarrasses Elinor in front of Mrs Jennings, and Marianne makes things worse by angrily defending her. Elinor believes Lady Middleton changes the subject out of dislike for such teasing, while Colonel Brandon, 'mindful of the feelings of others', helps her. The chapter contrasts Marianne's openness with Elinor's private pain.

  13. Chapter 13

    Brandon changes colour on reading his letter and will say only that it is business requiring him in town at once, which spoils the outing because he alone can gain them entry to Whitwell. Everyone presses him, and Willoughby sneers to Marianne that he wrote the letter himself to avoid a party of pleasure; Marianne agrees. Brandon bows to Marianne without a word as he leaves. Mrs Jennings gossips about Miss Williams, and later has her maid question Willoughby's groom to learn where he took Marianne. When Elinor objects that Marianne went into a house whose owner she has never met, Marianne argues that if she had done wrong she would have felt it, so her pleasure proves her innocence. Elinor answers that pleasure does not prove propriety, and her hint that the house may one day be Marianne's own pleases her sister, who describes its rooms with delight.

  14. Chapter 14

    Mrs Jennings tries out every possible reason for Brandon's departure, from money troubles on his Delaford estate to Miss Williams to his sister at Avignon, each seeming as likely as the last. Elinor is more puzzled by the silence of Marianne and Willoughby. She can see that they might not be able to marry at once, since Willoughby is independent but not rich, and lives beyond the six or seven hundred a year Sir John says his estate brings. The silence is so unlike them that she sometimes doubts they are engaged at all, and that doubt stops her asking. Willoughby protests against any improvement to the cottage, saying he would rebuild his own house, Combe, on the same plan, and Elinor drily mentions the dark narrow stairs and smoking kitchen. His speech is full of tender hints aimed at Marianne, and Mrs Dashwood readily gives the promise he asks for.

  15. Chapter 15

    Willoughby speaks bitterly of Mrs Smith exercising 'the privilege of riches upon a poor dependent cousin', says he will not return to Devonshire soon, and stammers that his engagements are 'of such a nature' before leaving. Elinor fears either that he never meant anything serious or that the lovers have quarrelled. Mrs Dashwood builds a full explanation: Mrs Smith suspects his love for Marianne, has invented the business to send him away, and he dare not reveal the engagement. She accuses Elinor of taking 'evil upon credit' rather than good. Elinor admits there is much in this, but points out that the couple have never said a word about an engagement, and that silence almost outweighs everything else. Marianne meanwhile cannot eat or speak, and the narrator notes that she has no power over herself because she has no wish for it.

  16. Chapter 16

    The narrator treats Marianne's sleepless night with irony: she would have thought it 'inexcusable' to sleep, and 'Her sensibility was potent enough!' She deliberately feeds her sorrow with music, books and solitary walks. Mrs Dashwood explains the lack of letters by Sir John's habit of fetching the post, and refuses to ask Marianne directly, a choice the narrator calls 'romantic delicacy' in which common sense is sunk. Marianne's cry that Willoughby will be back within weeks reassures Elinor a little. On the walk Marianne mistakes a rider for Willoughby, and he turns out to be Edward, whose confusion and lack of warmth towards Elinor seem to Marianne like coldness. Her rapture over dead leaves and the view meets Edward's plain remark about dirty lanes, and Elinor, though hurt, hides her feelings and checks Marianne's rudeness about the Middletons.

  17. Chapter 17

    Edward rejects his family's ambition for public distinction and wants happiness on his own terms. Marianne dismisses money's importance until her idea of a modest income proves twice the amount Elinor calls wealth. Elinor distinguishes courtesy in behaviour from surrendering independent judgement, refusing Marianne's account of her principles. Edward admits that shyness can make him seem inattentive, but responds with disproportionate embarrassment when Marianne calls him reserved.

  18. Chapter 18

    Edward's withdrawal from a chance to be alone with Elinor renews the puzzle of his behaviour. Their talk about scenery distinguishes practical enjoyment from fashionable language, while Elinor suspects his rejection of affected taste becomes an affectation of its own. His embarrassment over the ring leads Elinor to a confident private explanation despite her having given him no hair. The chapter allows her to be both perceptive about manners and capable of forming a pleasing conclusion on incomplete evidence. Edward teases Marianne after the visitors' hints, but does not grasp how seriously she feels about Willoughby.

  19. Chapter 19

    Edward describes how disagreement over a profession has left him idle and without independence. His insistence on leaving contradicts his declared enjoyment, but Elinor uses his mother's unknown character to explain what she cannot understand. Her continued attention to family life prevents grief from being unnecessarily increased without proving that she feels little. The Palmers' visit introduces another marriage in which outward manners and inner happiness are difficult to judge from shared behaviour.

  20. Chapter 20

    Mr Palmer's contemptuous remarks are welcomed by his wife as entertaining rather than painful. Elinor suspects that appearing superior motivates much of his deliberate ill-breeding. Charlotte's account of knowing Willoughby collapses into admissions that she has never spoken to him and seldom had a chance to meet him. Her account of a marriage announcement similarly turns a look into certainty, demonstrating how friendly conversation can circulate wishes and assumptions as established facts.

  21. Chapter 21

    Lady Middleton's anxiety about unknown guests disappears when the Steeles praise and indulge her children. Elinor recognises the calculation in that attention and remains unimpressed by declarations of friendship. Anne's questions about young men contrast with Lucy's efforts to repair her indiscretions. Sir John's publication of private guesses makes Elinor's supposed attachment common knowledge, while Lucy minimises her acquaintance with Edward.

  22. Chapter 22

    Lucy's questions about Mrs Ferrars lead to a disclosure she carefully watches Elinor receive. Elinor tests what she hears against names, dates and material evidence rather than accepting it immediately. The portrait, letter and account of Edward's visit to Plymouth defeat her hope of a mistake. Lucy's confidence also binds Elinor to silence, so composure protects her while she hears details overturning her own earlier interpretations.

  23. Chapter 23

    Elinor's review of the evidence separates what she knows about the engagement from what she believes about Edward's feelings. Her sympathy for his supposed unhappiness tempers her anger without removing his responsibility for remaining at Norland. She reads Lucy's confidence as a warning prompted by jealousy and resolves to protect both the secret and herself. At the Park, her tact pleases Lady Middleton while securing the private conversation that Marianne's open dislike of cards could not obtain.

  24. Chapter 24

    Lucy's account of waiting for financial independence makes the engagement depend on Mrs Ferrars's power as well as the couple's feelings. Elinor answers her professions of constancy with controlled questions and private scepticism. The proposed appeal to John Dashwood tests whether Lucy can turn her rival into a useful ally, but Elinor points out the stronger family connection through Fanny. Lucy's invitation to advise a separation produces another contest over apparent impartiality, and neither woman gains greater trust in the other.

  25. Chapter 25

    The invitation exposes the sisters' different reasons for wanting either to visit or avoid London. Marianne's willingness to overlook Mrs Jennings's manners reveals how completely reunion with Willoughby occupies her. Elinor agrees partly to care for Marianne and partly to spare their hostess the consequences of her sister's disregard. Her attempt to weaken the family's expectations about Edward fails, while Mrs Dashwood's confident anticipation of pleasure helps carry the plan forward.

  26. Chapter 26

    Elinor sustains polite conversation during the journey while Marianne attends almost entirely to her own expectations. Marianne's letter makes Elinor infer an engagement, but the narrative presents that conclusion through the sister who is still trying to understand the relationship. Brandon's arrival turns an anticipated reunion into visible disappointment, which Elinor tries to disguise as illness. Repeated waiting, questioning and frustrated attempts to read show hope making ordinary activities intolerable, while Willoughby's silence strengthens Elinor's wish for an explanation.

  27. Chapter 27

    Marianne turns even the weather into evidence supporting her hopes, first explaining Willoughby's absence and then anticipating his arrival. Her accusation that Elinor confides in nobody makes secrecy a barrier between sisters, although Elinor cannot honourably reveal Lucy's confidence. Social gossip and a letter seen in a servant's hand persuade Brandon of an engagement that the family has never confirmed. Elinor chooses reassurance stronger than her actual knowledge to protect Marianne's reputation and discourage Brandon's hopes, leaving her troubled by his suffering.

  28. Chapter 28

    The public reunion places Marianne's affectionate expectations against Willoughby's carefully formal behaviour. His avoidance of her eyes and hand makes the emotional distance visible before he offers any explanation. Elinor struggles to protect Marianne from the crowd while postponing questions that cannot be answered privately there. Afterwards she interprets Willoughby's embarrassment as evidence of a conscience and a former attachment, but these remain her attempts to explain conduct whose full cause she does not know.

  29. Chapter 29

    The exchange of letters exposes the gulf between Marianne's understanding of intimacy and Willoughby's formal denial of obligation. Elinor condemns his cruelty while also recognising the risk of Marianne's unconfirmed assumptions. Marianne's insistence that affection bound them as firmly as a legal agreement shows why the absence of a promise offers her little comfort. Her belief that Elinor cannot suffer because Edward loves her also reveals how little outward composure tells her about her sister's private grief.

  30. Chapter 30

    Mrs Jennings's practical remedies can be clumsy, but Elinor recognises the genuine kindness behind them. Her account of Miss Grey's fortune suggests money as an explanation for Willoughby's choice, without establishing it as his complete motive. Elinor tries to limit gossip and correct the assumption of a formal engagement, yet finds that doing so may expose Marianne more than it helps her. Mrs Jennings expects Brandon to welcome a rival's removal, while his continuing gravity shows how badly this expectation fits his concern for Marianne.

  31. Chapter 31

    Marianne's rejection of Mrs Jennings's sympathy contrasts with the narrator's account of that woman's goodwill. Brandon's painful narrative then gives his apparently dull gravity a history of strong attachment and loss. After finding the elder Eliza confined for debt and dying, Brandon arranged comfortable lodgings and attended her through her last days. The linked experiences of mother and daughter expose coercion, financial dependence and abandonment through his personal account rather than an abstract argument. His disclosure also explains earlier mysteries, including the interrupted outing, while his hesitation shows the difficulty of using private suffering to correct Marianne's idealised view of Willoughby.

  32. Chapter 32

    Knowledge of Willoughby's conduct ends Marianne's defence of him without immediately relieving her grief. Each sister accepts remaining in London partly because she imagines it will benefit the other, though Marianne misunderstands Elinor's situation. The neighbours' responses range from noisy indignation to Lady Middleton's polite indifference, which Elinor finds unexpectedly restful. Lucy's hints restore another pressure on Elinor's self-command, while her protection of Marianne from intrusive visitors shows how much quiet work that composure enables.

  33. Chapter 33

    The toothpick-case episode presents fashionable refinement as elaborate self-importance without consideration for others. John's conversation similarly exposes the gap between respectable appearances and practical generosity. His purchases and planned greenhouse undermine his claim to poverty, while he measures Marianne's illness chiefly through its effect on her marriage prospects. By imagining a marriage or legacy for Elinor, he turns relief of his own neglected responsibility into a reason for welcoming wealthy acquaintances.

  34. Chapter 34

    Fanny and Lady Middleton's mutual approval rests on shared coldness beneath correct manners. Mrs Ferrars's welcome to Lucy is dramatically ironic because she does not know which guest is secretly engaged to Edward. The grand dinner exposes John's claims of poverty while the repetitive conversation reveals another kind of scarcity. Marianne's defence of Elinor is both loving and uncomfortable for its recipient, and John's final explanation again reduces feeling to appearance and marriage value.

  35. Chapter 35

    Lucy's triumphant account of the dinner disguises hostility as gratitude for Elinor's friendship. Edward's arrival makes the concealed relationships immediately difficult to manage, and Elinor bears most of the work of conversation. The narrator distinguishes Lucy's relative indifference, Edward's troubled conscience and Elinor's justified composure. Marianne's praise becomes painful dramatic irony because her confidence in Edward and Elinor's happiness rests on the very ignorance that Elinor's promise requires her to preserve.

  36. Chapter 36

    The imposed visits reveal how little polite invitations guarantee mutual enjoyment. Robert's account of his own social superiority and extravagant cottage taste extends the vanity first displayed at the jeweller's. John's brief impulse to entertain his sisters again yields to Fanny's convenient objections, and postponement pacifies his conscience. Lucy gains a real opportunity from this selfish avoidance, so even Elinor begins to think her skilful flattery may overcome the family's resistance.

  37. Chapter 37

    Public discovery finally lets Elinor correct Marianne's assumption that composure means slight feeling. Her account explains restraint as painful work sustained by promises and concern for others, and Marianne recognises how unfairly she has judged her. John's report calls the family's coercion generous and Edward's constancy unfeeling, reversing the values endorsed by Mrs Jennings. The threatened transfer of property to Robert shows how money becomes a means of enforcing obedience, while Edward's refusal preserves his commitment at severe cost.

  38. Chapter 38

    Marianne recognises Elinor's example but turns the comparison into self-reproach rather than immediate change. Anne's uncontrolled report provides information while exposing the unfair means by which she obtained it. Elinor limits what she repeats, maintaining a distinction between knowledge and permission to circulate it. Lucy's letter presents herself as the one who offered release, and its affectionate acknowledgements also recruit the recipients' influence for Edward's advancement.

  39. Chapter 39

    Elinor persuades Marianne to accept Cleveland by appealing to her desire to see their mother rather than arguing directly against her fears. The narrative then shows Mrs Jennings building a confident interpretation from fragments of an overheard conversation. The full account replaces imagined courtship with practical benevolence, as Brandon acts against the cruelty of Edward's family. Elinor gratefully accepts the commission even though it appears to advance Edward's marriage to Lucy, while Brandon and she differ over whether the income can support that marriage.

  40. Chapter 40

    The prolonged conversation lets identical words sustain different stories because neither woman checks what the other means. Edward's unexpected arrival makes Elinor deliver personally the news she had found difficult even to write. Her insistence that his own merit prompted Brandon's generosity tries to spare him an obligation to her, though his response suggests further uncertainty about their relationship. The eventual correction amuses Mrs Jennings without diminishing her pleasure in the good news, while Elinor still anticipates Edward's marriage with pain.

  41. Chapter 41

    Lucy's gratitude immediately includes plans to profit from Brandon's resources, while John cannot explain his generosity without imagining a hidden transaction. Elinor's questions expose the contradictions in calling Mrs Ferrars affectionate after her rejection of Edward. The proposed substitution of Robert for Edward treats Miss Morton's wishes as irrelevant to the arrangement. Robert's laughter and self-satisfaction further contrast outward confidence with the integrity for which Edward has been punished.

  42. Chapter 42

    Leaving London relieves Elinor but painfully separates Marianne from the place of her former hopes. At Cleveland, Marianne turns landscape and solitude into opportunities to sustain her sorrow. Elinor's revised estimate of the Palmers distinguishes sincere hospitality from polished manners while retaining criticism of their faults. Her observation of Brandon's unspoken concern supports her belief that he loves Marianne, whose neglected cold closes the chapter with a practical consequence of her solitary habits.

  43. Chapter 43

    The illness tests everyone's judgement, including Elinor's earlier confidence that rest would restore Marianne. Mrs Jennings's practical nursing and refusal to leave reveal the sustained kindness that Marianne had dismissed. Brandon converts alarm into effective arrangements, while Elinor struggles with fear that she has summoned their mother too late. The recovery produces silent gratitude rather than outward gaiety, and the unexpected arrival turns her anticipation of relief into another confrontation.

  44. Chapter 44

    Willoughby's account acknowledges selfishness while repeatedly asking Elinor to recognise the sincerity of his suffering. His explanation connects vanity, expensive habits and financial calculation to the choices that injured both women. Elinor resists his attempt to shift blame onto Eliza or his wife, distinguishing compassion from absolution. Although his distress changes her estimate of his heart, she maintains that his marriage was his own choice and that his continuing desire for Marianne cannot justify further disloyalty. He now says Mrs Smith dismissed him after learning of Eliza and offering forgiveness if he married her. His claim that Sophia dictated the letter forms part of his defence, but he admits copying it to protect his wealthy engagement.

  45. Chapter 45

    Elinor subjects her own sympathy for Willoughby to scrutiny, recognising attractions that should carry no moral weight. Her mother's arrival brings relief but also another confident interpretation of a possible marriage. Mrs Dashwood's account mixes Brandon's actual disclosure with embellishments of her own imagination, repeating a habit that previously favoured Willoughby. Elinor grounds her esteem for Brandon in sustained knowledge rather than a single service and makes Marianne's happiness a necessary condition of her approval. Her momentary wish that Willoughby might be widowed, followed by self-reproof, shows that her own responses still need correction.

  46. Chapter 46

    Returning home tests Marianne's resolution against objects and places charged with painful memories. Her new plans for study and family life show purposeful effort, though Elinor notices the familiar tendency to excess even in self-improvement. Marianne's account of the illness is a severe judgement on her own conduct, which the narrative presents as her reflection rather than an impartial medical explanation. Her gratitude and concern for Elinor mark a wider attention to others, while hearing Willoughby's explanation gives that change an immediate emotional test.

  47. Chapter 47

    Reflection moderates Elinor's sympathy for Willoughby, allowing her to separate explanation from restored trust. The sisters discuss how his expensive habits and concern for his own comfort could have undermined a marriage even with genuine affection. Thomas's report then brings apparent confirmation of Edward's marriage, but identifies the husband only as Mr Ferrars. The family's interpretation produces real distress and prompts Mrs Dashwood to see how her attention to Marianne's openly expressed suffering has obscured Elinor's needs.

  48. Chapter 48

    Elinor's reaction distinguishes preparing for loss from experiencing what she believes to be its certainty. Her thoughts about Edward and Lucy's future remain painful projections, unsupported by further news. The awkward visit prolongs the error through ambiguous names until a direct question finally resolves it. Elinor's sudden tears reveal the feeling beneath her repeated attempts at composure, while Edward's absorption leaves the rest of the family unsure what will follow.

  49. Chapter 49

    The reunion gives Edward freedom to acknowledge mistakes that secrecy had prevented him from explaining. His account links the early engagement to idleness and inexperience without denying that his conduct at Norland encouraged false expectations. Lucy's release letter and the transfer of wealth to Robert reveal the ironic result of Mrs Ferrars's attempt to control marriage through property. Happiness still requires a workable income, and the discussion of reconciliation mixes legitimate regret with the uncomfortable practical need to seek favour.

  50. Chapter 50

    The ending gives Elinor and Edward domestic security without making Mrs Ferrars consistently just or affectionate. Lucy's success satirically rewards persistent self-interest, while the supposed harmony around her is undercut by jealousy and quarrels. Marianne's later marriage overturns her earlier rules about first attachments and age, combining family pressure with a choice the narrator explicitly calls voluntary. Her growing love for Brandon preserves the strength of her feeling while changing its object, and the final emphasis on the sisters' continued friendship makes family affection part of their fulfilled lives.

Key quotes

her disposition was affectionate, and her feelings were strong; but she knew how to govern them: it was a knowledge which her mother had yet to learn; and which one of her sisters had resolved never to be taught.
Chapter 1

Elinor is shown to feel deeply, not coldly; the difference is that she controls her feelings. The sentence sets her against Marianne and their mother from the start.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

She was generous, amiable, interesting: she was everything but prudent.
Chapter 1

Marianne's virtues are listed warmly before the single sting at the end. Prudence, the quality she lacks, is exactly what Elinor has.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

He was not an ill-disposed young man, unless to be rather cold hearted and rather selfish is to be ill-disposed
Chapter 1

The narrator seems to defend John and then undercuts him in the same breath. This dry irony is typical of how the narrator judges characters.

Family duty and selfishnessMoney, inheritance and greed

Five hundred pounds would be a prodigious increase to their fortunes!
Chapter 2

John has just halved his own gift, yet he talks of it as if it were lavish. The exclamation shows how easily he persuades himself that less is generous.

Money, inheritance and greedFamily duty and selfishness

Altogether, they will have five hundred a year amongst them, and what on earth can four women want for more than that?
Chapter 2

Fanny, who lives in comfort at Norland, decides what is enough for four women with no other income. Her question shows how dependent the Dashwood women are on the goodwill of others.

Money, inheritance and greedWomen's dependence and security

he finally resolved, that it would be absolutely unnecessary, if not highly indecorous, to do more for the widow and children of his father, than such kind of neighbourly acts as his own wife pointed out.
Chapter 2

The promise to a dying father ends as almost nothing, and John now thinks doing more would be improper. The formal, reasonable tone makes the betrayal more biting.

Family duty and selfishnessMoney, inheritance and greedManners, society and sincerity

I have never yet known what it was to separate esteem and love.
Chapter 3

Mrs Dashwood treats approval and love as the same thing, so she leaps straight to marriage. It shows where Marianne's own eagerness comes from.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

He admires as a lover, not as a connoisseur.
Chapter 3

Marianne wants love and taste united in one person. Her neat phrase reveals how much she judges people by their show of feeling for art.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

To hear those beautiful lines which have frequently almost driven me wild, pronounced with such impenetrable calmness, such dreadful indifference!
Chapter 3

Marianne's exaggerated language, 'driven me wild' and 'dreadful indifference', shows her sensibility. She cannot believe that calm on the surface could hide real feeling.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

Esteem him! Like him! Cold-hearted Elinor! Oh! worse than cold-hearted! Ashamed of being otherwise.
Chapter 4

Marianne mistakes Elinor's careful words for a lack of feeling. The broken exclamations dramatise the emotional intensity she expects love to display.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

to wish was to hope, and to hope was to expect.
Chapter 4

The neat chain shows how quickly Marianne and her mother turn a wish into a certainty. Elinor, by contrast, waits for evidence.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

I am very much mistaken if Edward is not himself aware that there would be many difficulties in his way, if he were to wish to marry a woman who had not either a great fortune or high rank.
Chapter 4

Elinor sees that love is not free of money and rank. Her clear view of Edward's dependence on his mother is the sense that Marianne lacks.

Love and marriageMoney, inheritance and greedSense and sensibility: reason and feeling

he seemed rather to stand in need of more money himself than to have any design of giving money away.
Chapter 5

The narrator's dry comment closes the story of John's promise. A rich man talks as if he were the one in need.

Money, inheritance and greedFamily duty and selfishness

No leaf will decay because we are removed, nor any branch become motionless although we can observe you no longer!
Chapter 5

Marianne speaks to the trees as if they were friends, in the style of romantic poetry. She is aware, though, that nature carries on without regard for her feelings.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

till all these alterations could be made from the savings of an income of five hundred a year by a woman who never saved in her life
Chapter 6

The narrator gently mocks Mrs Dashwood's hopeful plans. Her imagination runs ahead of her means, as Marianne's runs ahead of the facts.

Money, inheritance and greedSense and sensibility: reason and feeling

though perfectly well-bred, she was reserved, cold, and had nothing to say for herself beyond the most commonplace inquiry or remark.
Chapter 6

Lady Middleton has every outward grace but no warmth. The novel separates good manners from real feeling.

Manners, society and sincerity

On every formal visit a child ought to be of the party, by way of provision for discourse.
Chapter 6

The mock rule pokes fun at polite visits where people have nothing to say to each other. A child becomes a topic of conversation.

Manners, society and sincerity

Sir John was a sportsman, Lady Middleton a mother. He hunted and shot, and she humoured her children; and these were their only resources.
Chapter 7

The balanced sentences sum up a whole marriage in a few words. The narrator shows that wealth and hospitality do not bring taste or depth.

Manners, society and sincerityLove and marriage

Colonel Brandon alone, of all the party, heard her without being in raptures. He paid her only the compliment of attention
Chapter 7

Brandon's quiet attention is set against the loud, empty praise of the others. Real respect does not need a show.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingManners, society and sincerity

she was reasonable enough to allow that a man of five and thirty might well have outlived all acuteness of feeling and every exquisite power of enjoyment.
Chapter 7

The narrator calls Marianne 'reasonable' while reporting a very unreasonable opinion. The irony shows how her ideas about feeling make her judge others too quickly.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

It would be an excellent match, for he was rich, and she was handsome.
Chapter 8

Mrs Jennings reduces marriage to a simple trade of money for beauty. Austen's short sentence makes the reasoning sound comic.

Love and marriageMoney, inheritance and greed

To me it would seem only a commercial exchange, in which each wished to be benefited at the expense of the other.
Chapter 8

Marianne rejects marriage without love as mere business. Her view stands against the money talk heard throughout the opening chapters, though she is harsh about a woman of twenty-seven.

Love and marriageMoney, inheritance and greedWomen's dependence and security

Even now her self-command is invariable.
Chapter 8

Marianne means it as a criticism of Elinor. To the reader, self-command looks like Elinor's strength.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

His person and air were equal to what her fancy had ever drawn for the hero of a favourite story
Chapter 9

Marianne meets Willoughby through the lens of fiction. The narrator shows that her feelings are shaped by the stories she has read before she knows anything about him.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

But Marianne could no more satisfy him as to the colour of Mr. Willoughby's pointer, than he could describe to her the shades of his mind.
Chapter 9

The balanced sentence sets Sir John's world of sport against Marianne's world of feeling. Neither can give the other the information they want.

Manners, society and sinceritySense and sensibility: reason and feeling

Whatever be his pursuits, his eagerness in them should know no moderation, and leave him no sense of fatigue.
Chapter 9

Marianne praises the very lack of moderation that Elinor would question. Her ideal man is as eager and unrestrained as she is.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

I have erred against every commonplace notion of decorum; I have been open and sincere where I ought to have been reserved, spiritless, dull, and deceitful
Chapter 10

Marianne turns Elinor's joke into an attack on polite society, as if reserve were the same as deceit. It states her belief that showing feeling openly is always honest and right.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingManners, society and sincerity

whom everybody speaks well of, and nobody cares about; whom all are delighted to see, and nobody remembers to talk to.
Chapter 10

Willoughby's neat, witty sentence dismisses Brandon without any real charge against him. Elinor calls such judgements prejudiced and unjust.

Manners, society and sinceritySense and sensibility: reason and feeling

and sense will always have attractions for me. Yes, Marianne, even in a man between thirty and forty.
Chapter 10

Elinor names the quality she values most, and her teasing aside answers Marianne's scorn for the colonel's age. The word 'sense' links her directly to the novel's title.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

to aim at the restraint of sentiments which were not in themselves illaudable, appeared to her not merely an unnecessary effort, but a disgraceful subjection of reason to commonplace and mistaken notions.
Chapter 11

Marianne believes reason itself is on her side when she refuses to hide her feelings. The sentence shows that her sensibility is a principle she has thought out, not just a mood.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingManners, society and sincerity

Everything he did, was right. Everything he said, was clever.
Chapter 11

The short, flat sentences mimic Marianne's total admiration. The narrator's irony shows that love has taken away her power to judge.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

there is something so amiable in the prejudices of a young mind, that one is sorry to see them give way to the reception of more general opinions.
Chapter 11

Brandon values Marianne's romantic ideas even as he expects them to change. His gentle view softens Elinor's wish that Marianne would learn more of the world.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

It is not time or opportunity that is to determine intimacy; it is disposition alone. Seven years would be insufficient to make some people acquainted with each other, and seven days are more than enough for others.
Chapter 12

Marianne trusts instant sympathy over long knowledge. Her example, that she knows her brother John less than Willoughby, shows how she ranks feeling above time and duty.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriageFamily duty and selfishness

But, Marianne, the horse is still yours, though you cannot use it now. I shall keep it only till you can claim it.
Chapter 12

Willoughby speaks as if their future together were settled. Elinor reads the use of her sister's first name as proof of an understanding between them.

Love and marriageManners, society and sincerity

who was on every occasion mindful of the feelings of others
Chapter 12

The narrator's praise of Brandon comes as he quietly rescues Elinor from teasing. It sets his tact against the noise of Mrs Jennings and the mockery he receives from Willoughby.

Manners, society and sincerity

I would lay fifty guineas the letter was of his own writing.
Chapter 13

Willoughby, who has no evidence, accuses Brandon of lying to escape the party. Marianne's 'I have no doubt of it' shows how readily she shares his prejudice.

Manners, society and sinceritySense and sensibility: reason and feeling

that the pleasantness of an employment does not always evince its propriety.
Chapter 13

Elinor separates what feels good from what is right. Her careful, Latinate phrasing is typical of how she reasons.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingManners, society and sincerityWomen's dependence and security

we always know when we are acting wrong, and with such a conviction I could have had no pleasure.
Chapter 13

Marianne makes her own feelings the test of right and wrong. Set beside Elinor's reply, it states the novel's central debate clearly.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

she was a great wonderer, as everyone must be who takes a very lively interest in all the comings and goings of all their acquaintance.
Chapter 14

The narrator gently mocks Mrs Jennings's curiosity. Her noisy guessing contrasts with Elinor's quiet, unspoken questions about her sister.

Manners, society and sincerity

With dark narrow stairs and a kitchen that smokes, I suppose
Chapter 14

Elinor's dry humour punctures Willoughby's romantic speech about the cottage. She reminds him of the real discomforts of living on a small income.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingMoney, inheritance and greed

Tell me that not only your house will remain the same, but that I shall ever find you and yours as unchanged as your dwelling
Chapter 14

Willoughby asks the family for a promise of lasting affection while making no open promise himself. It shows how strongly he attaches himself to them.

Love and marriageFamily duty and selfishness

You had rather take evil upon credit than good.
Chapter 15

Mrs Dashwood sees Elinor's caution as a gloomy wish to think badly of people. The line shows how she mistakes hope for knowledge.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

I want no proof of their affection," said Elinor; "but of their engagement I do.
Chapter 15

Elinor distinguishes apparent affection from an acknowledged commitment. The family have inferred a promise that neither Marianne nor Willoughby has confirmed.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriageWomen's dependence and security

She was without any power, because she was without any desire of command over herself.
Chapter 15

The narrator suggests that Marianne's grief is partly chosen. She treats self-command as something she does not want, not something she cannot reach.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

Marianne would have thought herself very inexcusable had she been able to sleep at all the first night after parting from Willoughby.
Chapter 16

The narrator mocks the idea that grief must be shown to be real. Marianne feels it a duty to suffer as much as possible.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

common sense, common care, common prudence, were all sunk in Mrs. Dashwood's romantic delicacy.
Chapter 16

The repeated 'common' stresses the plain good sense that Mrs Dashwood sets aside. Her kindness to Marianne becomes a failure of parental duty.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

It is not everyone," said Elinor, "who has your passion for dead leaves.
Chapter 16

Elinor gently teases Marianne's romantic raptures. Marianne's reply, that her feelings are only 'sometimes' understood, turns her thoughts back to Willoughby.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

Your competence and my wealth are very much alike
Chapter 17

Elinor exposes how different words can disguise the sisters' shared desire for material comfort.

Money, inheritance and greedSense and sensibility: reason and feeling

All I have ever attempted to influence has been the behaviour.
Chapter 17

She separates treating neighbours considerately from accepting their opinions as true.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingManners, society and sincerity

to avoid one kind of affectation, Edward here falls into another.
Chapter 18

Elinor recognises that claiming unusual plainness can itself become a way of performing a taste.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingManners, society and sincerity

procured by some theft or contrivance unknown to herself.
Chapter 18

She invents an explanation that allows the ring to confirm his affection without checking the actual origin of the hair.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

it was at least prevented from unnecessary increase
Chapter 19

Elinor's activity does not erase sorrow, but it limits the additional suffering her choices might produce.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

It is so ridiculous!
Chapter 19

Charlotte converts her husband's failure to answer into a source of amusement, unsettling the Dashwoods' expectations of affection.

Love and marriageManners, society and sincerity

It was the desire of appearing superior to other people.
Chapter 20

Elinor interprets Mr Palmer's discourtesy as a performance of distinction rather than simply spontaneous ill temper.

Manners, society and sinceritySense and sensibility: reason and feeling

he looked as if he knew it to be true, so from that moment I set it down as certain.
Chapter 20

Charlotte's explanation exposes how little supports the confident news she first attributes to Colonel Brandon.

Manners, society and sinceritySense and sensibility: reason and feeling

to be together was, in his opinion, to be intimate
Chapter 21

Sir John mistakes proximity for a friendship that depends on mutual choice and understanding.

Manners, society and sinceritySense and sensibility: reason and feeling

With such a reward for her tears, the child was too wise to cease crying.
Chapter 21

Indulgent attention gives the child a reason to prolong her distress.

Family duty and selfishnessManners, society and sincerity

Elinor's security sunk; but her self-command did not sink with it.
Chapter 22

Loss of hope is separated from loss of outward control, showing the feeling hidden by her manner.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

I certainly did not seek your confidence
Chapter 22

Elinor identifies a disclosure imposed on her while accepting responsibility for keeping it secret.

Manners, society and sincerityFamily duty and selfishness

She was stronger alone
Chapter 23

Privacy lets Elinor bear her suffering without also managing her family's reactions.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

contradicted by nothing but her own wishes.
Chapter 23

The narrator distinguishes Elinor's desire from the evidence that defeats it.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

my interest would do very little.
Chapter 24

Elinor refuses the influence Lucy tries to assign her over Edward's prospects.

Money, inheritance and greedManners, society and sincerity

nothing had been said on either side to make them dislike each other less than they had done before
Chapter 24

Polite conversation conceals a rivalry that explanation has failed to soften.

Manners, society and sincerityLove and marriage

the sole guidance of her own judgment
Chapter 25

Elinor's concern about Marianne's judgement helps explain why she accepts an unwelcome visit.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

Elinor conjectured that she might as well have held her tongue.
Chapter 25

Her family's established expectations about Edward resist even her cautious correction.

Family duty and selfishnessLove and marriage

the post of civility which she had assigned herself
Chapter 26

Elinor treats courtesy to their hostess as a responsibility requiring active work.

Manners, society and sincerityFamily duty and selfishness

the anxiety of expectation and the pain of disappointment
Chapter 26

The paired phrases make waiting an exhausting alternation between hope and distress.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

you, because you do not communicate, and I, because I conceal nothing.
Chapter 27

Marianne opposes reserve to openness even while their relationship remains unexplained to Elinor.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

to say more than she really knew or believed.
Chapter 27

Elinor's protective purpose leads her beyond the caution about evidence she usually practises.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingManners, society and sincerity

it was beyond her wish.
Chapter 28

Marianne does not merely fail to compose herself: she resists concealing the feeling she regards as justified.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

This is not the place for explanations.
Chapter 28

Elinor recognises how the crowded setting prevents the private account Marianne urgently needs.

Manners, society and sincerityFamily duty and selfishness

It was every day implied, but never professedly declared.
Chapter 29

Marianne distinguishes an attachment she felt certain of from words Willoughby actually spoke.

Love and marriageSense and sensibility: reason and feeling

Happy, happy Elinor, you cannot have an idea of what I suffer.
Chapter 29

Marianne mistakes restrained expression for freedom from sorrow, deepening the sisters' painful misunderstanding.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

we shall do very well with or without Colonel Brandon.
Chapter 30

Elinor places Marianne's recovery ahead of Mrs Jennings's immediate plans for another match.

Family duty and selfishnessLove and marriage

its healing powers, on a disappointed heart might be as reasonably tried on herself as on her sister.
Chapter 30

The wine briefly reveals the shared suffering concealed by the sisters' different outward behaviour.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

Her kindness is not sympathy; her good-nature is not tenderness.
Chapter 31

Marianne treats the form of comfort as a test of its sincerity, despite the narrator's contrary account.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingManners, society and sincerity

he neither returned, nor wrote, nor relieved her.
Chapter 31

The repeated negatives make Willoughby's abandonment a sustained refusal of responsibility.

Women's dependence and securityLove and marriage

She felt the loss of Willoughby's character yet more heavily than she had felt the loss of his heart
Chapter 32

Marianne grieves not only for affection but for the good person she believed him to be.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

the clamorous kindness of the others.
Chapter 32

The phrase recognises good intentions while showing how noisy sympathy can burden its recipient.

Manners, society and sinceritySense and sensibility: reason and feeling

a happy air of real conceit and affected indifference.
Chapter 33

The contrast distinguishes the young man's genuine vanity from the unconcern he performs.

Manners, society and sincerity

He had just compunction enough for having done nothing for his sisters himself, to be exceedingly anxious that everybody else should do a great deal
Chapter 33

The narrator makes John's concern a means of transferring responsibility rather than accepting it.

Money, inheritance and greedFamily duty and selfishness

no poverty of any kind, except of conversation, appeared
Chapter 34

The narrator turns John's claims of financial hardship into a judgement on the gathering's emptiness.

Money, inheritance and greedManners, society and sincerity

Miss Morton is Lord Morton's daughter.
Chapter 34

Mrs Ferrars answers a question about artistic merit with rank, revealing the basis of her preference.

Manners, society and sincerityLove and marriage

his heart had not the indifference of Lucy's, nor could his conscience have quite the ease of Elinor's.
Chapter 35

The narrator explains their different discomforts through feeling and responsibility rather than manners alone.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

the most scrupulous in performing every engagement
Chapter 35

Marianne's intended praise painfully touches the binding promise she does not know Edward has made.

Love and marriageFamily duty and selfishness

they feel injured by the expectation of anything better from them.
Chapter 36

The narrator exposes Fanny's resentment of being expected to show ordinary family kindness.

Family duty and selfishnessManners, society and sincerity

she did not think he deserved the compliment of rational opposition.
Chapter 36

Elinor's agreement with Robert is a withholding of serious engagement rather than admiration.

Manners, society and sinceritySense and sensibility: reason and feeling

Yes. But I did not love only him;
Chapter 37

Elinor explains that responsibility to family and friends shapes how she expresses romantic grief.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

the effect of constant and painful exertion
Chapter 37

Her composure is an achievement requiring effort, rather than evidence of emotional coldness.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

the torture of penitence, without the hope of amendment.
Chapter 38

Marianne's remorse remains painful but ineffective while she believes present effort impossible.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

a conversation which you ought not to have known yourself.
Chapter 38

Elinor challenges the intrusion behind Anne's information rather than simply enjoying its usefulness.

Manners, society and sinceritySense and sensibility: reason and feeling

What had really passed between them was to this effect.
Chapter 39

The narrator explicitly corrects the confident story Mrs Jennings has constructed from partial evidence.

Manners, society and sinceritySense and sensibility: reason and feeling

my pleasure in presenting it to him will be very great.
Chapter 39

Brandon makes his power useful to Edward, contrasting with the family's financial threats.

Money, inheritance and greedFamily duty and selfishness

The unkindness of your own relations has made you astonished to find friendship anywhere.
Chapter 40

Elinor sets Brandon's generosity against the treatment Edward has received from his family.

Family duty and selfishnessMoney, inheritance and greed

of course, to reflect on her own with discontent.
Chapter 40

The narrator punctures the apparent cheerfulness of Elinor's anticipation by returning to her private feelings.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

The lady, I suppose, has no choice in the affair.
Chapter 41

Elinor challenges a marriage calculation that treats the brothers as interchangeable holders of wealth.

Women's dependence and securityMoney, inheritance and greedLove and marriage

A very simple one
Chapter 41

Elinor's answer about Brandon's motive rejects John's elaborate attempts to explain generosity as profit-seeking.

Money, inheritance and greedManners, society and sincerity

precious, invaluable misery
Chapter 42

The contradictory description captures Marianne's attachment to experiences that intensify her grief.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

her folly, though evident was not disgusting, because it was not conceited
Chapter 42

Elinor's judgement of Charlotte distinguishes limited understanding from self-important pretension.

Manners, society and sinceritySense and sensibility: reason and feeling

acted with all the firmness of a collected mind
Chapter 43

Brandon's strong feeling supports purposeful action rather than preventing it.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

satisfaction, silent and strong.
Chapter 43

Elinor's inward joy, like her grief, exceeds what an observer might infer from her expression.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

Your indifference, however, towards that unfortunate girl
Chapter 44

Elinor confronts the emotional neglect behind his effort to explain his treatment of Eliza.

Women's dependence and securityLove and marriage

You had made your own choice. It was not forced on you.
Chapter 44

She refuses to let regret turn a voluntary marriage into an excuse for mistreating his wife.

Love and marriageSense and sensibility: reason and feeling

rather in proportion, as she soon acknowledged within herself, to his wishes than to his merits.
Chapter 45

Elinor admits that the compassion Willoughby sought has exceeded what his conduct deserves.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

if Marianne can be happy with him
Chapter 45

Her conditional support leaves room for Marianne's feelings within her mother's eager marriage scheme.

Love and marriageFamily duty and selfishnessWomen's dependence and security

The future must be my proof.
Chapter 46

Marianne makes sustained conduct, rather than present remorse alone, the test of her resolution.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

introducing excess into a scheme of such rational employment and virtuous self-control.
Chapter 46

Elinor sees continuity in her sister's temperament even as its intended direction changes.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingFamily duty and selfishness

My happiness never was his object.
Chapter 47

Marianne accepts a distinction between Willoughby's affection and sustained concern for her welfare.

Love and marriageSense and sensibility: reason and feeling

misled by the careful, the considerate attention of her daughter
Chapter 47

Elinor's effort to spare her mother has unintentionally hidden the extent of her own pain.

Family duty and selfishnessSense and sensibility: reason and feeling

the difference between the expectation of an unpleasant event, however certain the mind may be told to consider it, and certainty itself.
Chapter 48

The narrator shows why Elinor's long preparation has not removed the shock of supposed confirmation.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feeling

burst into tears of joy
Chapter 48

Release from the mistaken belief breaks the control she has worked so hard to sustain.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

I am doing no injury to anybody but myself.
Chapter 49

Edward recalls the self-excusing argument that ignored how his continuing visits could affect Elinor.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

they only wanted something to live upon.
Chapter 49

The narrator brings mutual affection and approval back to the material conditions of marriage.

Money, inheritance and greedLove and marriage

with no other sacrifice than that of time and conscience.
Chapter 50

The narrator's apparently encouraging account of Lucy's success becomes a sharp moral qualification.

Money, inheritance and greedManners, society and sincerity

Marianne could never love by halves;
Chapter 50

Her new attachment changes her earlier opinions without erasing the emotional intensity of her character.

Sense and sensibility: reason and feelingLove and marriage

Talking points

These questions discuss the whole novel, including the ending. Compare feelings with conduct, and examine how money, manners and incomplete knowledge shape the sisters' choices.

  1. Does Elinor's self-command limit feeling or make room for other people?

    Compare the narrator's introduction, the concealed engagement and the explanation to Marianne. Consider both the benefits of restraint and the misunderstandings it allows.

    "Yes. But I did not love only him;"

    Chapter 37

    Look again at: Chapter 1, Chapter 22, Chapter 37, Chapter 48

  2. How does Marianne change without ceasing to be recognisably herself?

    Compare her early opinions about attachment and age with her plans after illness and her eventual marriage. Attend to the narrator's reservations about excess and to the time taken for her new love to grow.

    Look again at: Chapter 8, Chapter 10, Chapter 46, Chapter 50

  3. What makes kindness convincing when manners are awkward or unwelcome?

    Set Marianne's judgements of Mrs Jennings beside the journey, nursing and departure from Cleveland. Compare practical care with Lady Middleton's polished indifference.

    Look again at: Chapter 26, Chapter 31, Chapter 32, Chapter 43, Chapter 46

  4. How does the novel expose the use of money to excuse neglect or enforce obedience?

    Compare John and Fanny's early calculations, John's account of his expenses, Mrs Ferrars's threats and Brandon's gift. Ask what responsibilities each person accepts or transfers to others.

    Look again at: Chapter 2, Chapter 33, Chapter 37, Chapter 39, Chapter 41

  5. How far should Willoughby's explanation change judgement of his conduct?

    Read Brandon's account beside Willoughby's defence and Elinor's later reflections. Distinguish sincere affection, regret, blame and responsibility towards Eliza, Marianne and his wife.

    "You had made your own choice. It was not forced on you."

    Chapter 44

    Look again at: Chapter 31, Chapter 44, Chapter 45, Chapter 47

  6. What does the novel show about the danger of treating appearances as evidence?

    Compare assumptions about Marianne's engagement, Mrs Jennings's interpretation of Brandon's conversation and the report of Mr Ferrars's marriage. Consider how the narration lets readers see an error being formed.

    Look again at: Chapter 27, Chapter 29, Chapter 39, Chapter 40, Chapter 47, Chapter 48

  7. Why does Lucy succeed, and does success amount to approval?

    Trace her confidence to Elinor, her cultivation of the Ferrars family, her release letter and the narrator's account of her final prosperity. Examine irony in the description of family harmony.

    "with no other sacrifice than that of time and conscience."

    Chapter 50

    Look again at: Chapter 22, Chapter 34, Chapter 36, Chapter 38, Chapter 49, Chapter 50

  8. How much freedom do women have within the novel's marriage arrangements?

    Compare the two Elizas, the proposed substitution of Robert for Edward as Miss Morton's husband, and the pressure surrounding Marianne's final marriage. Include what the narrator says about voluntary choice and later affection.

    Look again at: Chapter 31, Chapter 41, Chapter 50